Adult Child Claims Against a Parent’s Estate in NSW

If you are an adult child and your parent’s will left you nothing, or far less than you expected, you may be able to ask the NSW Supreme Court for a larger share of the estate. This is called a family provision claim. A child of the deceased is automatically an “eligible person” under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), but being eligible is only the start: you must also show the provision made for you was not adequate, and the clock is short.

This guide explains how an adult child claim works in NSW, what the court weighs, what it can cost, and how stepchildren, grandchildren and spouses fit in.

Simons George Legal
Assess Your Estate Claim
Simons George Legal advises on family provision claims and estate disputes, with strategies tailored to your family and financial circumstances.

Visit Simons George Legal

TL;DR

  • A child of the deceased, including an adult child, can apply for a family provision order under section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).
  • The application must be filed in the Supreme Court within 12 months of the date of death. Late claims need the court’s permission.
  • There is no automatic right to an equal share. The court looks at your financial need, your relationship with the deceased, the size of the estate and competing claims.
  • An unsuccessful applicant can be ordered to pay the other side’s costs, so an early, honest assessment of the claim matters.
  • Stepchildren, grandchildren and spouses can sometimes claim too, but different tests apply.

Table of Contents

Do adult children have a right to inherit in NSW?

No. NSW law gives people wide freedom to decide who receives their estate. A parent can leave an adult child out of a will, and the will is not invalid because they did.

What the law does give is a safety valve. The Supreme Court can order that provision be made from the estate for certain people if the will did not make adequate provision for their proper maintenance, education or advancement in life. The NSW Supreme Court says the family provision jurisdiction regularly deals with claims by adult children, and that each is decided on its own facts rather than on any assumption of an equal share.

Two points catch people out:

  • It is not a challenge to the will’s validity. The will stands. The court reallocates part of the estate, as Legal Aid NSW explains. If you instead doubt the will was properly made, that is a different kind of dispute, covered in our page on contesting or challenging a will.
  • You do not have to wait for probate. A claim can be filed before a grant of probate has been issued.

Who counts as an eligible person

Section 57 lists who may apply. According to Legal Aid NSW, the list includes the deceased’s spouse, a de facto partner, a child (including an adopted child) and a former spouse, along with certain dependants and household members. The full wording is in the Succession Act 2006.

The categories split into two groups:

Group Who What you must show
Automatically eligible Spouse, de facto partner, child of the deceased You are in the category; then the court asks whether provision was adequate
Eligible with an extra step Former spouse, a dependent grandchild, a dependent household member, a person in a close personal relationship with the deceased That you fit the category and that there are factors which warrant the application

An adult child sits in the first group. That removes one hurdle, but it does not mean the claim will succeed.

What the court looks at in an adult child claim

The court first asks whether the deceased left you adequate provision for your proper maintenance, education or advancement in life. If not, it considers whether to make an order and how much. Section 60 of the Act sets out a list of factors the court may consider. The ones that carry weight in most adult child cases are:

  1. Your financial position. Income, assets, debts, earning capacity and living costs.
  2. Age, health and disability. A child with a chronic illness or limited capacity to work stands in a very different position from one with a secure career.
  3. The relationship with the deceased. Contact, care given, contributions to the parent’s wellbeing or property, and any estrangement.
  4. The size and nature of the estate. A modest estate cannot stretch to every claimant.
  5. Competing claims. A surviving spouse or other dependants often have strong needs. The Supreme Court notes that courts weigh competing claims against each other.
  6. Other provision already made. Gifts during the parent’s lifetime, or benefits outside the will.
  7. The deceased’s reasons. What the parent wrote or said about why they left you out, and whether those reasons hold up.

Legal Aid NSW stresses that family provision is about adequate provision, not fairness in the abstract. In practice, a financially secure adult child faces a much higher hurdle than one who is struggling.

A worked example

Imagine a mother leaves her $900,000 home to one son, who cared for her for years, and nothing to her daughter. The daughter is 58, has chronic health problems, rents, and has little superannuation. The son is financially comfortable. The daughter’s need is real, and the estate is large enough to meet it without leaving the son with nothing. That is a claim worth assessing carefully.

Now change the facts: the daughter earns a high income, owns her home outright, and has had no contact with her mother for decades. The same estate, but a much weaker claim. This is an illustration only, not a prediction: outcomes turn on the evidence in each case.

Comparison of two adult child claim profiles

Estrangement

Estrangement does not shut the door, and it does not guarantee success. The court looks at who caused it, how long it lasted, and whether the parent’s reasons for excluding you were fair. If this is your situation, our article on estranged family member inheritance rights in NSW goes into more detail.

The 12-month deadline

This is the rule that ends more claims than any other. Under section 58 of the Act, an application must be filed with the Supreme Court within 12 months of the date of death. Legal Aid NSW repeats the same time limit and advises eligible people to get advice from a private lawyer.

The court can extend the time only on sufficient cause or by consent of the parties. You should not plan on getting an extension. If the deadline has passed, see our guide to family provision claims out of time in NSW. If it has not, move early: gathering evidence and negotiating takes months, and the 12 months run from the date of death, not from when you learned of the will.

How a claim runs, step by step

  1. Get the will and a picture of the estate. Find out who the executor is, what the main assets are, and who else benefits.
  2. Assess the claim. A lawyer looks at your need, your history with the deceased, the estate and the likely costs.
  3. Collect evidence. Financial records, medical reports, evidence of care or contact. Our documentation checklist for inheritance disputes lists what to gather.
  4. Negotiate. Many claims settle through correspondence or mediation before any hearing.
  5. File in the Supreme Court if needed. Filing within time protects your position while talks continue.
  6. Mediation. Legal Aid NSW notes that these proceedings almost always involve mediation before a final hearing.
  7. Hearing and judgment if no settlement is reached.

For a fuller walk-through, see our family provision claim process guide for NSW.

Costs and risk

Litigation has a price, and you should count it before you start. Legal Aid NSW warns that an unsuccessful applicant can be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party, which may be the estate or other beneficiaries. That makes the relationship between the size of the estate and likely legal costs a central question.

A sensible assessment asks:

  • What is the realistic range of an order, given the estate and the competing claims?
  • How much will it cost to run the claim to mediation, and to a hearing?
  • Is there a settlement route that gets close to the likely outcome without a trial?

Our overview of estate litigation settlement options covers how these cases commonly resolve.

What about stepchildren, grandchildren and spouses?

Many people reach this topic through a related question, so here is where each sits.

Stepchildren. A stepchild is not automatically a “child” for these purposes. A stepchild may still qualify if they were dependent on the deceased and were part of the deceased’s household, which falls in the second group in the table above. That means showing factors that warrant the application. The detail of the facts matters: how long you lived in the household, what support you received, and what the deceased’s own children received.

Grandchildren. The same extra step applies. A grandchild must have been wholly or partly dependent on the deceased, and then show factors warranting the application. A grandchild whose parent has died, or who was raised or supported by a grandparent, has the more natural case.

Spouses and de facto partners. A spouse or de facto partner is automatically eligible, and often has the strongest claim because the court considers the partner’s need and their contribution to the relationship. A surviving partner’s claim can reduce what is left for adult children, which is why competing claims need early attention.

Each of these claimants faces the same 12-month deadline.

What about stepchildren, grandchildren and spouses? — overview diagram

Adult child maintenance is a different thing

Searching this topic also turns up “adult child maintenance”, and it is easy to confuse the two. Adult child maintenance is a payment from a parent who is alive, usually for an adult child with a disability or in ongoing study. Legal Aid NSW describes how to apply for, or respond to, those orders. Ordinary child support generally stops when a child turns 18, with a possible extension to the end of secondary school.

A family provision claim is for after a parent has died. If your parent is still alive and you are worried about their will, there is nothing to claim yet, but there may be useful planning steps for the parent.

Our perspective

We act in this area every week, and our view is simple: the claims that go well are the ones assessed honestly on day one. Adult children often arrive feeling that a parent’s will was unfair, and sometimes it was. But fairness is not the legal test, and we say so plainly in the free first meeting, whichever way it cuts.

Three things we look for early:

  • Evidence of need that is current and documented. Not a general sense of hardship, but figures.
  • A realistic view of the estate. If legal costs would consume most of what a court might award, we say that.
  • A route that avoids the hearing. Most disputes are better resolved at mediation, with the court filing preserving your position.

We also act for executors and beneficiaries defending claims, so we know how the other side builds its case. Every matter is partner-led, and we aim to keep costs proportionate to what is at stake.

— George

When to speak to a lawyer

Talk to a wills and estates lawyer as soon as you know a parent has died and you are unhappy with, or unsure about, what you received. Do it sooner if any of these apply:

  • Months have already passed since the death.
  • You are a stepchild, grandchild or household member rather than a child.
  • The estate is mostly one asset, such as a family home or a farm.
  • A surviving spouse or another child is likely to resist.
  • You are the executor, or a beneficiary, and a claim has been made against the estate.

Our Family Provisions Claims service covers claimants, and our Defend An Estate service covers executors and beneficiaries responding to a claim. We work with clients in Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW, in person or by video. The first 30 minutes is free. For the broader picture, read our guide on what to do when there is not enough in a will.

If you are the parent: reducing the risk of a dispute

This topic matters to people making wills as well as to those challenging them. If you want to leave an adult child less than their siblings, the safest approach is to plan for it openly. Record your reasons in a way your lawyer advises, keep your financial records and lifetime gifts clear, and consider structures such as a testamentary trust where a child is vulnerable. Poorly drafted wills cause their own litigation, as we explain in our pieces on mutual wills pitfalls and life interest versus right to reside. Our Making & Amending A Will team can help you put a plan in place.

Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you know where you stand before committing to anything. For people with a legitimate claim, this removes the upfront cost barrier that so often stops them from acting at all. Not every matter qualifies, and we will tell you honestly if yours does not. Read how it works on our No Win, No Fee page, then book your free case assessment today.

No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Your next step

Write down the date of death today and count 12 months forward. Then gather the will, a list of what you know about the estate, and your own financial records. With those in hand, a 30-minute conversation is usually enough to tell you whether a claim is worth pursuing and how to go about it. You can start at Simons George Legal.

FAQ

Can a parent legally disinherit an adult child in NSW?

Yes, a parent can leave an adult child out of a will. However, the child may still apply to the Supreme Court for provision as an eligible person. Whether the court makes an order depends on the child’s need, the estate and other claims.

How long do I have to make a claim?

You must file within 12 months of the date of death. The court can extend this only on sufficient cause or by consent, so treat the deadline as firm.

Do I need to wait for probate before claiming?

No. A claim can be filed before a grant of probate is issued. Waiting can eat into the 12 months, so seek advice early.

Can I lose money by making a claim?

Yes. If the claim fails, the court can order you to pay the costs of the successful party. That is why the claim should be assessed against the size of the estate before proceedings are filed.

Can a stepchild or grandchild contest a will?

Sometimes. They are not automatically eligible, but may qualify if they were dependent on the deceased and, for a stepchild, part of the household. They must also show factors that warrant the application.

Sources