The golden rule is a good-practice guideline for solicitors in NSW. When a will-maker is elderly or seriously ill, the solicitor should arrange for a medical practitioner to assess their capacity and understanding, and should make a record of that assessment at the time. It is not a statute, and a will is not invalid just because the rule was skipped. But in a dispute, the evidence the rule produces is often what decides whether a will stands.
This guide explains what the rule asks for, how it differs from the legal test for capacity, how NSW courts have treated it, and what to do if you are an executor or beneficiary facing a will you doubt or need to defend.
TL;DR
- The golden rule is a recommendation to get a contemporaneous medical assessment of capacity when the will-maker is aged or seriously ill. It is not a rule of law.
- Following it does not guarantee a will is valid, and not following it does not make a will invalid. Courts look at all the evidence.
- The legal test for capacity is the Banks v Goodfellow test, which asks about understanding, property, claims and mental disorder.
- Records made at the time of signing, such as medical notes and the solicitor’s attendance notes, carry the most weight.
- If you suspect incapacity or undue influence, preserve the records early and get advice before probate steps are taken.
Table of Contents
- What the golden rule actually says
- Is the golden rule a legal requirement?
- The legal test: Banks v Goodfellow
- How the golden rule and the capacity test fit together
- When should a medical assessment be arranged?
- How NSW courts treat the golden rule in validity disputes
- What evidence shows capacity
- If you are an executor or beneficiary who doubts a will
- If you are an executor defending a will
- Applying the golden rule when you make your own will
- Our perspective
- Talk to a Sydney wills and estates lawyer
- Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
- Where to start
- FAQ
- Sources
What the golden rule actually says
In academic commentary on Australian succession law, the golden rule is described as a recommendation: where a will-maker is aged or seriously ill, the solicitor should arrange for a medical practitioner to assess capacity and understanding and make a contemporaneous record of the assessment. The purpose is to avoid, or at least minimise, disputes after death.
Three practical points sit inside that short statement.
- The trigger is vulnerability. The rule is aimed at will-makers who are elderly, unwell, or showing signs of cognitive decline. A healthy 35-year-old making a first will is not the target.
- The assessment is made by a doctor, not the lawyer. The solicitor takes instructions and forms a view, but the medical practitioner provides an independent opinion on understanding.
- The record must be made at the time. An opinion written years later, after a dispute begins, is far weaker than notes created when the will was signed.
Think of it as insurance paid before the event. The cost is a doctor’s appointment and a few extra pages on the file. The benefit, if the will is ever challenged, is a body of evidence that nobody can reconstruct afterwards.
Is the golden rule a legal requirement?
No. The academic commentary is clear that the rule is a recommendation for good practice rather than a rule of law affecting validity. Compliance is not a touchstone of validity, and non-compliance does not demonstrate that a will is invalid.
This matters for both sides of a dispute:
- If you are defending a will, you cannot rely on a doctor’s letter alone to close the matter. A court will still weigh everything.
- If you are challenging a will, you cannot win simply by pointing out that no medical assessment was obtained. You need evidence that capacity was in fact missing, or that there are other grounds.
The golden rule therefore sits alongside the legal test rather than replacing it.
The legal test: Banks v Goodfellow
Whether a will-maker had testamentary capacity is decided under the test from Banks v Goodfellow. In Zorbas v Sidiropoulous (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 197, the NSW Court of Appeal identified the governing questions. Did the will-maker:
- understand the nature and effect of the will;
- understand the extent of their property;
- understand the claims to which they ought to give effect; and
- have a mind free of any disorder or delusion that affects how they distribute their property?
The academic commentary notes that these elements remain the present-day requirements for will-making capacity in Australia.
Two refinements are worth knowing.
Knowing your estate does not mean knowing every asset. Zorbas cautions that understanding the extent of an estate does not necessarily require knowledge of every asset or its precise value. The court applies the underlying principle to the circumstances. A will-maker who cannot recite the balance of every account is not automatically incapable.
Capacity is a judicial question, not purely a medical one. The court in Zorbas treated the criteria as matters for commonsense judgment on the whole of the evidence, not directly medical questions, although medical evidence may be highly relevant. That is why a doctor’s opinion helps but does not end the inquiry.
For a deeper look at how capacity is assessed in practice, see our guide to testamentary capacity in NSW.
How the golden rule and the capacity test fit together
The easiest way to see the relationship is this: the Banks v Goodfellow test is the question, and the golden rule is a method of gathering the answer.
| Golden rule | Banks v Goodfellow test | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Good-practice recommendation for solicitors | Legal test applied by the court |
| Who it addresses | The drafting solicitor | The judge deciding validity |
| When it applies | Aged or seriously ill will-makers | Every will, if capacity is put in issue |
| Effect on validity | None by itself | Decisive |
| Output | Contemporaneous medical and file record | A finding on capacity |
A solicitor who follows the golden rule is not guaranteeing capacity. They are creating the best possible evidence on the very questions the court will later ask.
When should a medical assessment be arranged?
The Law Society of NSW says the golden rule is relevant when a client is very ill. Its guidance recommends obtaining the doctor’s opinion if possible, but not delaying an urgent will for that reason.
That balance is important. A person who is in hospital and may not survive the week should not be left without a will because an appointment cannot be found. A will signed promptly, with careful notes, is better than no will and an intestacy.
The same guidance says that in urgent cases involving a very ill client, the solicitor should take instructions directly from the will-maker, preferably alone or, where needed, with a qualified interpreter who is not a family member. Taking instructions privately matters because it removes the most common source of later allegations: that a relative was in the room and shaped the outcome.
Signs that a medical assessment is wise
In our experience, these situations call for a medical assessment before signing, time permitting:
- a diagnosis of dementia, cognitive impairment or a progressive neurological condition;
- recent hospitalisation, delirium or significant medication changes;
- a will-maker who depends on one family member for daily care and transport;
- a sudden change to a long-standing will that cuts out a child or spouse;
- a will that leaves most of the estate to a carer, new partner or a person who arranged the appointment.
These are the facts that disappointed family members later point to. Having the answer on file before the question is asked is the whole idea.
How NSW courts treat the golden rule in validity disputes
NSW courts do not treat compliance as conclusive or non-compliance as automatically fatal. In a validity dispute the court applies the Banks v Goodfellow test, scrutinises the whole of the evidence, and may require the person propounding the will to answer a sufficient doubt about capacity.
Who has to prove what
Zorbas explains that where a sufficient doubt about capacity is raised, the party propounding the will must satisfy the court that it is valid. A mere doubt is not enough. The doubt must be sufficient to prevent the court from finding for the will. In practice, that means a challenger needs real evidence of something wrong, such as a medical history, odd circumstances of signing or an irrational result, rather than a feeling that the will-maker “wasn’t themselves”.
Phillips v Phillips: records carry the day
In Phillips v Phillips [2017] NSWSC 280, the Supreme Court considered whether the will was facially rational and duly executed, whether the circumstances raised doubt about capacity, and whether the propounder had proved capacity on the balance of probabilities. The court held that contemporaneous medical records, independent expert evidence, lay evidence and the solicitor’s evidence can all be relevant, and it placed primary weight on reliable contemporaneous records.
The case is a cautionary one for those defending a will. The court treated the lack of reliable independent witnesses, and the solicitor’s inability to establish capacity beyond permitting the will to be signed, as significant weaknesses. Capacity was not proved.
Wild v Meduri: capacity and knowledge are separate questions
In Wild v Meduri [2023] NSWSC 113, the court separately decided whether the deceased had testamentary capacity and whether the deceased knew and approved the contents of the will. It found yes on both in that case. The lesson is that a will can fail on knowledge and approval even where capacity is intact, and the reverse. Our page on knowledge and approval of wills covers when a caveat is the right first step.
The academic commentary adds that courts prefer contemporaneous evidence of capacity to retrospective specialist diagnoses in appropriate cases, particularly where the solicitor followed careful capacity-assessment practices.
What evidence shows capacity
Pulling the research together, the useful evidence in a capacity dispute usually includes:
- Contemporaneous medical records and assessments, made around the date of the will.
- An independent expert opinion, which can help interpret those records, though a retrospective opinion carries less weight than notes made at the time.
- Reliable lay evidence from people who saw the will-maker around the time, ideally with no stake in the outcome.
- The drafting solicitor’s attendance notes and observations: what was asked, how the will-maker answered, who was present.
- Direct recordings or testimony showing that the will-maker understood their family, their assets and the proposed gifts.
No single item is a trump card. The court weighs the lot, and records made at the time can be particularly persuasive.
What good attendance notes look like
A solicitor following the golden rule will typically record that the will-maker was seen alone, was asked open questions rather than leading ones, described their family and main assets in their own words, explained why they were treating each family member as they were, and understood what the will would do. Notes that simply say “client appeared well” add little. Specific answers in the will-maker’s own words add a great deal.
If you are an executor or beneficiary who doubts a will
Suspicion is not evidence. The research is plain that a bare suspicion of incapacity or undue influence is not enough. What is enough is a well-organised body of material that speaks to capacity at the date of the will, the circumstances in which instructions were given and the will signed, knowledge and approval, and any influence or suspicious circumstances.
If you are in that position, the early steps are practical:
- Secure records. Ask for the will-maker’s medical records, hospital and aged care notes where you are entitled to them, and identify the solicitor who drafted the will so their file can be preserved.
- List witnesses. Note who saw the will-maker in the months around signing, including carers, neighbours and friends, and write down what each recalls while memories are fresh.
- Collect communications. Emails, messages and letters about the will, the appointment and the will-maker’s wishes can be telling.
- Get advice before probate moves. If an application for probate is coming, a caveat may be a sensible way to hold the position while you gather evidence. The timing is a legal question, so speak to a solicitor early.
- Mind the time limits. Family provision claims in NSW have strict deadlines, so read our guide to eligibility, time limits and costs early.
A will can be attacked on grounds other than capacity. Our overview of the grounds for contesting a will sets out undue influence, fraud, lack of knowledge and approval and formal defects. If your concern is a signature or document that may not be genuine, see our page on forged wills in NSW. If your issue is that the will is valid but leaves you too little, a family provision claim may be the better route, and our guide to not enough in a will explains it.
If you are an executor defending a will
Executors are often caught in the middle. You have a duty to carry out the will, and you may be named in a challenge that you did not expect. The same evidence list applies, but now it is your job to assemble it.
Start with the drafting solicitor’s file, including the notes of the instructions meeting and the signing. Locate the witnesses to the will; the formal requirements are summarised in our guide to witness rules for signing a will in NSW. Gather any medical evidence from near the signing date. Do not distribute assets while a challenge is live without advice, because that can create personal exposure.
Where a family provision claim is made against the estate, our executor’s guide to defending a family provision claim explains your obligations and options.
Applying the golden rule when you make your own will
The best time to deal with capacity is before anyone could dispute it. If you are making or updating a will, and any of the following apply, tell your solicitor at the first meeting:
- you have been diagnosed with a condition that may affect memory or judgement;
- you expect your family to be surprised by your decisions;
- you are leaving someone out who might reasonably expect to be included;
- someone close to you is helping organise the appointment.
In those circumstances, a short medical assessment of capacity near the signing date, with the doctor’s note kept on the solicitor’s file, is cheap protection. Record your reasons too. A clear explanation, ideally in a separate statement, helps a court understand a decision that might otherwise look irrational.
The State Library of NSW describes a will as a legal document naming your beneficiaries, specific gifts and the person you trust to administer the estate. NSW Government guidance adds that a will sets out how assets are to be distributed, and that dying without one means dying intestate, in which case the law, not you, decides who inherits. A well-documented will avoids both problems.
Our perspective
We act on both sides of capacity disputes, and the pattern is consistent: the matters that run longest and cost families most are the ones where nobody recorded anything at the time.
The golden rule is not a formality. It is the cheapest way to turn an argument about someone’s state of mind into a matter of documents. When we draft a will for a person who is unwell or elderly, we want the medical opinion, the private instructions meeting and the detailed notes on file before the pen touches paper, without delaying anything that is genuinely urgent.
When a will is already in dispute, every matter is partner-led by a specialist with Supreme and High Court experience. We start by finding out what evidence exists, what can still be preserved and what the realistic outcome looks like, then we give you plain advice on whether to negotiate, mediate or run the case. We aim to keep costs proportionate to what is at stake.
George
Talk to a Sydney wills and estates lawyer
Whether you are planning a will that needs to withstand scrutiny, or facing an estate where capacity is in doubt, we can assess your position quickly. New clients receive a complimentary 30-minute consultation, and we see clients in person or virtually across Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW.
If you want a will drafted with capacity evidence built in, see our will drafting and amendment service. If you are already in a dispute, our estate litigation team can review the evidence and explain your options, and you can also start with the Simons George Legal home page.
Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
We offer No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you know where you stand before committing to anything. For people with a legitimate claim, this removes the upfront cost barrier that can stop a valid challenge or defence from being brought at all. Read more on our No Win, No Fee page, then book your free case assessment today and we will tell you plainly whether your matter qualifies.
No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Where to start
If you are making a will for someone who is unwell, act promptly and arrange a medical opinion if it can be done without delay. If you are contesting or defending a will, begin with the records. Then choose the pathway that fits: negotiation, mediation or court. Our guide to why estate disputes go to court and our overview of settlement options will help you weigh them.
FAQ
Is the golden rule law in NSW?
No. It is a recommendation for good practice by solicitors, not a rule of law. Following it does not prove a will is valid, and failing to follow it does not show a will is invalid. Courts decide capacity on all of the evidence.
Does every will in NSW need a doctor’s certificate?
No. The golden rule is aimed at will-makers who are aged or seriously ill. For many people, a careful solicitor’s meeting and file note is enough. If there is any doubt about capacity or a likelihood of family dispute, a medical assessment is wise.
What if the person was too ill to wait for a medical assessment?
The Law Society of NSW recommends getting the doctor’s opinion if possible, but not delaying an urgent will for that reason. The solicitor should take instructions directly from the will-maker, preferably alone, and keep detailed notes of what was said and observed.
Can a will be challenged if the golden rule was followed?
Yes. A medical assessment is strong evidence but not conclusive. A will can still be challenged on capacity, knowledge and approval, undue influence or other grounds, and the court will weigh all the evidence. Eligible persons may also bring a family provision claim regardless of validity.
What should I do first if I think a will-maker lacked capacity?
Preserve evidence: medical records, the drafting solicitor’s file, witness details and communications. Then get legal advice before probate is granted, because a caveat and the time limits for claims may affect your options.
Sources
- Sydney University Press law book chapter on testamentary capacity (AustLII, 2011)
- Zorbas v Sidiropoulous (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 197
- Phillips v Phillips [2017] NSWSC 280
- Wild v Meduri [2023] NSWSC 113
- Wills and Estates FAQs, The Law Society of NSW
- Wills, State Library of New South Wales
- Dealing with a will and estate after a death, NSW Government