If you have made, or been served with, a family provision claim in the NSW Supreme Court, mediation is the next big event. It is a confidential, structured negotiation run by a neutral mediator, and in the Supreme Court’s Probate and Family Provision List it is close to compulsory. Most claims that reach it are resolved there or soon after, which is why how you prepare matters so much.
This guide explains when mediation happens, what the court expects of you beforehand, what the day looks like, what it costs, and what your options are if the mediation does not settle the dispute.
TL;DR
- Under section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), the court must refer a family provision application to mediation before it is heard, unless there are special reasons not to.
- The 12-month deadline from the date of death still applies. Mediation does not pause it, so the claim must be filed first.
- Preparation decides outcomes: early disclosure of your finances and the estate’s position, a realistic costs estimate and a clear settlement range.
- Court-annexed mediation carries no mediator or room charge, but each party still pays its own lawyers.
- If mediation does not settle the claim, the matter continues towards a hearing, and negotiation often carries on in the meantime.
Table of Contents
- Why mediation sits at the centre of family provision claims
- Where mediation fits in the timeline
- What the court expects before mediation
- What happens on the day
- What it costs
- How to prepare: a practical approach
- Mediating as an executor or defendant
- Our perspective
- If mediation does not settle the claim
- How we can help
- Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
- FAQ
- Sources
Why mediation sits at the centre of family provision claims
A family provision claim is an application to the Supreme Court of NSW by an eligible person who says the will (or the intestacy rules) did not make adequate provision for them. The law is in Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). These claims are common: the ABC reported that 996 family provision claims were filed in the NSW Supreme Court in 2024, out of 1,461 contested estate matters in total.
Courts do not want every one of those claims to run to a final hearing. A hearing is slow, expensive and public in a way families rarely enjoy. Mediation is the court’s built-in way of giving the parties a serious chance to resolve things first. Section 98 of the Act requires the court to refer family provision applications to mediation before the hearing, unless special reasons make it inappropriate.
In practice, the Supreme Court’s Practice Note SC EQ 07 for the Probate and Family Provision List, issued on 13 June 2024, sets out how cases are managed. So although people talk about mediation as voluntary, in this list you should treat it as a step you will take, and plan for it from the day the claim is filed.
Where mediation fits in the timeline
A typical claim moves through these stages:
- Death and grant. The deceased passes away and, usually, probate or letters of administration are obtained.
- Filing. The applicant files the claim. Section 58 of the Act requires this within 12 months of the date of death, unless the court extends time on sufficient cause. An application is made on the day it is filed in the court registry.
- First directions. The court sets a timetable, including steps for evidence and disclosure.
- Mediation. The court refers the matter to mediation, commonly some weeks after the claim is first listed.
- Resolution or hearing. The claim settles, or it is prepared for hearing.
If you are still working out your timing, our guide to the family provision claim process in NSW walks through each stage in more detail.
The 12-month limit and the “3-year rule”
People often ask about a three-year rule. For family provision claims there is no such rule. The period is 12 months from the date of death. Extensions are possible, but you need to show sufficient cause and should never rely on one. If the deadline is close or has passed, get advice immediately, before thinking about mediation at all.
What the court expects before mediation
The most common surprise for first-time applicants and executors is how much work comes before the mediation day. The court wants the cards on the table early, so that the mediation is a real negotiation and not a first look at each other’s positions.
Under the practice note, the parties are expected to give early disclosure of their financial positions and of the state of the estate. As a practical matter, that means being ready to set out:
- For the applicant: your income, assets, liabilities, living arrangements, health, dependants and earning capacity, and your relationship with the deceased.
- For the executor or defendant: the estate’s assets and liabilities, the expected net value, any assets that may be notional estate, and who the beneficiaries are and what they would receive.
- For both: an estimate of legal costs to date and to the end of mediation and to the end of a hearing, because costs are a real part of any settlement calculation.
A costs estimate must be prepared carefully, and getting it wrong or late can hold the case up. The estate is not a bottomless pot. In many modest estates, legal costs on both sides can consume a large share of what is being fought over, and a good mediator will make sure everyone sees that number.
If you want a checklist of what to collect, see our inheritance dispute documentation checklist.
What happens on the day
Mediation formats vary, but a family provision mediation usually runs like this.
Opening
The mediator explains the process, confirms that discussions are confidential and without prejudice, and checks that each person attending has authority to settle. Executors should come with clear authority, and beneficiaries who are affected by the outcome should be present or represented.
Joint session and private sessions
Each side may briefly outline its position. After that the mediator often separates the parties into different rooms and carries offers and reasoning between them. This “shuttle” stage is where most movement happens, because people say things privately that they would never say across the table.
Negotiation and settlement
Offers go back and forth. When terms are agreed, they are recorded, ideally in a signed document at the session, and later turned into consent orders that the court approves. Because many family provision claims involve minors, people lacking capacity or beneficiaries with special needs, court approval may be required, and your lawyer should flag that early.
The Supreme Court’s own statistics use a narrow definition of “settled at mediation”: the parties have agreed final orders or signed heads of agreement by the end of the mediation. The court’s Dispute Resolution review notes that many other matters go on to settle soon after the session. So a mediation that ends without a signed deal has not necessarily failed. It may simply have narrowed the gap.
You will see figures such as 80% or higher quoted for the share of claims that settle at or around mediation. Treat these as rough indications from practitioners rather than guarantees. The honest takeaway is that the large majority of family provision claims never reach a judgment.
What it costs
The court explains that with court-annexed mediation there is no charge for the mediator or the use of rooms, and each party is responsible for its own legal representation. Private mediation usually involves mediator fees and room costs, which vary between mediators and are usually shared equally unless the parties agree otherwise or the court orders it.
The larger saving is against a hearing. The same court page notes that preparing for and presenting a case at hearing is generally more costly than preparing for mediation, that hearings carry a separate court fee, and that a judgment can include orders for an unsuccessful party to pay the other side’s costs. That exposure is a big reason sensible parties negotiate.
Legal costs often come out of the estate in the end, which means they reduce what every beneficiary receives, including the applicant if they succeed. That is worth remembering when you weigh a settlement offer against a hearing.
How to prepare: a practical approach
The people who do best at mediation are not the loudest. They are the best prepared. Work through these steps with your lawyer.
- Know your legal position. Are you an eligible person under section 57 of the Act? What are the strengths and weaknesses of your claim on need, relationship, contributions and the deceased’s obligations? Our guide to eligibility and outcomes for family provision claims in NSW covers the legal tests.
- Set a range, not a number. Agree with your lawyer a best outcome, a likely outcome and a walk-away point before the day. Include costs in that calculation.
- Gather evidence. Bank statements, medical evidence, housing costs, details of care you gave the deceased, and valuations of estate assets all give your offers credibility.
- Think about the other side’s pressure points. Executors worry about costs, delay and personal liability. Beneficiaries may worry about losing the family home or a business. Understanding that helps you design offers that can be accepted.
- Decide what non-money terms matter. A life interest, a transfer of a particular asset, a release of other claims or a staged payment can be as valuable as a lump sum.
- Keep emotions on a leash. Mediation will bring up old grievances. The mediator will let people be heard, but offers made out of anger are rarely good ones.
For strategy on the negotiation itself, see our estate dispute negotiation strategies.
Mediating as an executor or defendant
If you are the executor, the claim is not personal, even when it feels that way. Your duty is to the estate and its beneficiaries, and you should not use estate money to defend a claim in a way that puts you at risk of criticism. The court looks closely at the conduct of executors.
Useful points for executors at mediation:
- Bring up-to-date estate figures and know what is liquid and what is not.
- Be clear on who else must agree. A settlement that binds some beneficiaries but not others can unravel.
- Consider what the deceased’s reasons were for the will. Evidence of those reasons carries weight, though not unlimited weight.
- Do not distribute the estate while the claim is on foot without advice. The court can make orders affecting assets already distributed in some situations, and the safest course is to take advice first.
If you are facing a dispute and need a defence strategy, see our Defend An Estate page.
Our perspective
We act on both sides of these disputes, and the same pattern repeats. The families who come out best are rarely the ones who “win” the most dramatic argument. They are the ones who understand early what the estate can afford, what a court is likely to do and what a settlement is worth to them compared with a hearing.
Three things we tell clients before every mediation:
- Mediation is a hearing of a different kind. It is where the real decision usually gets made, so treat it as the main event, not a formality on the way to court.
- The best offers answer the other side’s real concern. An executor worried about delay will often trade a little money for certainty. A beneficiary worried about a house will often trade cash for the home.
- Costs belong in every conversation. We aim to keep costs proportionate to what is at stake, and we will tell you plainly when a claim is worth pursuing or defending and when it is not.
Every matter is partner-led by a specialist with extensive Supreme and High Court experience. That means the person who advises you on strategy is the person in the room.
— George
If mediation does not settle the claim
Sometimes the parties are too far apart, or one side has not engaged properly. That is not the end of negotiation. Several things can happen next:
- A second session or follow-up talks. Mediators often follow up by phone, and many matters settle in the days or weeks after a session, as the court’s own review observes.
- A formal offer. Offers made in the right form can have costs consequences if the other side later fails to beat them at hearing. Your lawyer can explain how that works in your case.
- Further evidence and a hearing date. The matter is prepared for final hearing before a judge, who decides whether adequate provision was made and what order, if any, should follow.
Other dispute resolution routes exist as well, such as private mediation, a settlement conference or negotiation between lawyers. Our overview of inheritance dispute resolution options in NSW compares them, and our guide to estate litigation settlement options explains how deals are structured and documented.
How we can help
We act for applicants, executors and beneficiaries in family provision claims across Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW, in person or virtually. We can assess your claim, prepare your disclosure and costs estimate, attend mediation with you and negotiate the terms. See our Family Provisions Claims page, or our Estate Litigation service if the matter looks likely to go further.
Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
Cost should not stop someone with a legitimate claim from being heard. Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you learn where you stand before committing to anything. That removes the upfront cost barrier for people with a genuine claim. If you think you may have one, book a free case assessment with us today and we will tell you plainly what we think.
No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
FAQ
Is mediation compulsory in a family provision claim in NSW?
Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) requires the Supreme Court to refer family provision applications to mediation before hearing unless there are special reasons not to. In practice, the court expects parties to mediate at the earliest practicable time. You should plan on attending.
How long after filing does mediation take place?
It varies with the court’s timetable and how quickly disclosure is completed. Many matters are mediated within a few months of filing, but you should not assume a date. Your lawyer will confirm the timetable set by the court’s directions.
What if I miss the 12-month deadline?
The claim must be filed within 12 months of the date of death, unless the court grants an extension on sufficient cause. Extensions are not automatic and depend on your reasons and the circumstances of the estate, so get legal advice as soon as you realise time is short.
Does anything said at mediation get used against me in court?
Mediation is confidential and conducted on a without prejudice basis, so what is said to the mediator and in negotiations is generally protected. Signed settlement terms are a different matter, as they bind you. Ask your lawyer to explain the protections before the session.
Do I need a lawyer at mediation?
You are not required to have one, but these are legal and financial negotiations with court-approved consequences. A lawyer helps you value the claim, avoid pitfalls in the settlement terms and make sure the agreement is turned into proper orders.
Sources
- Succession Act 2006 No 80, NSW Legislation
- Supreme Court Practice Note SC EQ 07, Probate and Family Provision List
- Supreme Court of NSW, Dispute Resolution review
- Supreme Court of NSW, Mediation
- ABC News, Lawyers urge Australians to ensure valid and up-to-date will is in place