If you have been served with a family provision claim in NSW, you can defend it, but the first few weeks matter. Respond on time, work out what the estate actually holds, keep distributions on hold, and get advice before you file anything. Most claims are decided on the applicant’s eligibility and financial position, not on whether the will is “fair”, so your response should be built around evidence rather than family history.
This guide is for executors, administrators and beneficiaries who have received a Summons from the Supreme Court of NSW. It explains what the claim is, what the court looks at, what you must do, and where mediation and costs fit in.
TL;DR
- A family provision claim does not say the will is invalid. It asks the court to order more provision from the estate for an eligible person.
- The claim must generally be brought within 12 months of the date of death, though the court can extend that time.
- As executor, your job is to put accurate estate information before the court and protect the estate, not to fight on a beneficiary’s behalf at any cost.
- Most claims go to mediation first, and costs can be ordered against an unsuccessful applicant.
- Hold off distributing assets until you have advice, and get it early.
Table of Contents
- What a family provision claim actually is
- Who is eligible to claim
- The time limit: 12 months, with exceptions
- What the court weighs
- What to do in the first weeks
- The executor’s role: neutral stakeholder or active defender?
- Mediation and settlement
- Who pays the costs
- Reducing the risk before a claim ever arrives
- Our perspective
- How we can help
- Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
- Your next steps
- FAQ
- Sources
What a family provision claim actually is
A family provision claim is an application under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). The applicant accepts that the will (or the intestacy rules) is valid. They say it left them without adequate provision for their maintenance, education or advancement in life, and they ask the court to order more.
That is different from contesting a will on grounds such as lack of capacity, undue influence or suspicious circumstances. Those challenges attack the document itself. If you are unsure which kind of claim you face, our overview of types of deceased estate claims in NSW sets them side by side.
For a defendant, the distinction shapes the whole response. You are not trying to prove the will is good. You are showing the court what the estate is, who else depends on it, and why the applicant’s claim should be refused or limited.
Who is eligible to claim
Not everyone with a grievance can bring a claim. Under section 57 of the Succession Act, eligible persons include the deceased’s spouse, de facto partner, child, former spouse, a grandchild who was dependent on the deceased, a person who lived in the same household and was dependent, and a person who was in a close personal relationship with the deceased at the time of death (Succession Act 2006 (NSW)).
Eligibility is the first gate, and it is worth checking before anything else. If the applicant is not an eligible person, the claim fails at the threshold. Adult children are eligible, but eligibility is only the start: they still have to persuade the court that further provision should be made.
For some categories of applicant, such as grandchildren and household members, the court must also be satisfied there are factors warranting the application. That is a further hurdle you can test.
The time limit: 12 months, with exceptions
Section 58(2) requires a family provision application to be made within 12 months of the date of death. The court can allow a later application if it finds sufficient cause, and parties can consent to an out-of-time application (Succession Act 2006 (NSW)).
Two practical points for defendants:
- Do not assume a late claim is dead. Courts can and do extend time. We explain how that works in family provision claims out of time in NSW.
- Do not agree to an extension casually. Consent from the parties is one route to a late claim. Take advice before you give it.
What the court weighs
The court may make an order under section 59 only if the applicant is an eligible person and adequate provision for their proper maintenance, education or advancement has not been made. If it is satisfied of that, the court then considers the matters in section 60 (Succession Act 2006 (NSW)). These include:
- the applicant’s relationship with the deceased
- the size and nature of the estate
- the applicant’s present and future financial needs and resources
- any physical, intellectual or mental disability
- the applicant’s age
- contributions the applicant made to the estate or to the deceased’s welfare
- the deceased’s intentions and any evidence of what the deceased said about their decisions
In practice, this means your evidence should cover three things: the applicant’s financial position (income, assets, debts, living arrangements), the competing needs of other beneficiaries, and the deceased’s reasons, where there is reliable evidence of them. A will-maker’s written explanation, file notes from the drafting solicitor and consistent past statements can all matter.
Notional estate
The court’s reach can extend beyond what passes under the will. Property that was jointly held, or certain assets moved before death, can be designated notional estate and made available to satisfy an order. If you are defending, you need to know early whether the applicant will argue this, because it changes the size of the pool and the risk to other beneficiaries.
What to do in the first weeks
The Supreme Court manages these claims through the Probate and Family Provision List under Practice Note SC EQ 07, which aims at the just, quick and cheap disposal of proceedings. A Summons must be made returnable before the Registrar in Probate no later than the first Thursday after 28 days from filing, so the timetable starts moving quickly.
A sensible sequence:
- Read the Summons and supporting affidavit closely. Note who the applicant says they are, what they claim, and what orders they want.
- Diarise the return date. If you intend to defend, you will generally need to enter an appearance. Check the current court requirements rather than relying on a general guide.
- Secure the estate. Make a list of assets, liabilities and who is entitled to what. If probate has not been granted, see probate vs administration and our executor checklist.
- Pause distributions. Paying out beneficiaries while a claim is live can leave you personally exposed if the estate can no longer meet an order. Get advice before releasing anything.
- Collect evidence. Gather the will file, medical and financial records, and anything showing the deceased’s reasoning and the applicant’s relationship with them.
- Tell the beneficiaries. They are affected and may need to be separately represented.
Our five-step plan for executors defending a will in NSW walks through this in more detail.
The affidavit you may be directed to file
The Registrar in Probate may direct the executor or administrator to file an affidavit setting out the estate’s assets and liabilities, any potential notional estate and the identity of the beneficiaries, together with a reply to the applicant’s affidavit (Practice Note SC EQ 07). This is the document the court and the other side will rely on to judge the estate, so it needs to be complete and accurate. An incomplete affidavit damages your credibility and can add to costs.
Justice Lindsay has described the case management in the Family Provision List as directed at early exchange of information so cases can be realistically assessed (Supreme Court speech, 2021). Expect to be asked for disclosure early, and plan for it.
The executor’s role: neutral stakeholder or active defender?
This is where executors get caught. Your duty is to the estate and to administering it according to the will and the law. In a family provision claim, that generally means putting the facts before the court and protecting the estate’s assets. It does not automatically mean taking sides with one beneficiary against another.
If you are also a beneficiary, your interests and your duties can pull apart. A common example is an executor who is also the main beneficiary and the applicant’s sibling. Advice on how to separate those roles, and whether others should be separately represented, is worth getting before you respond. If the applicant is also seeking to remove you, our estate litigation team can advise on both fronts.
Mediation and settlement
Most family provision claims are referred to mediation, and those that do not settle are listed for a final hearing (Legal Aid NSW). Under the Supreme Court’s practice note, parties are expected to attend court-annexed mediation in person unless there are exceptional circumstances, and sessions are generally listed for a half-day (SC EQ 07).
To get value from a half-day:
- Know the estate’s real net value before you walk in.
- Decide in advance what range of outcomes you can accept, and who has authority to agree.
- Bring the evidence that supports your position on the applicant’s resources and needs.
- Think about tax, property sale and timing consequences of any settlement, not just the headline figure.
We cover the range of outcomes in estate litigation settlement options.
Who pays the costs
The court has a broad discretion over costs, including the power under section 99 of the Succession Act to order them paid out of the estate or notional estate (Succession Act 2006 (NSW)). Legal Aid NSW notes that an unsuccessful applicant may be ordered to pay their own costs and the defendant’s costs (Legal Aid NSW).
There is no guarantee either way. Two lessons follow:
- Costs spent on a weak defence reduce what beneficiaries receive, so be proportionate.
- A reasonable, early offer can change the costs picture later. Take advice on how and when to make one.
Reducing the risk before a claim ever arrives
If you are reading this as a will-maker rather than an executor, the best defence is built while you are alive. Clear written reasons, up-to-date financial information, and structure all help. A testamentary trust can control how and when benefits pass to beneficiaries, and the trade-offs against a simple will are set out in this comparison of testamentary trusts and simple wills. Trustee and tax issues also need attention, as covered in this guide to testamentary trust pitfalls.
None of this makes a will claim-proof. A court can still order provision for an eligible person. But it can make the deceased’s intentions clearer and the estate harder to attack. If you want to review your own will, see making and amending a will or our list of common estate planning mistakes.
Our perspective
We see the same pattern in contested estates. The families who do best are not the ones who fight hardest. They are the ones who understand the estate early, face the applicant’s strongest argument honestly, and decide what a good outcome looks like before costs build up.
Every matter at Simons George Legal is partner-led by a specialist with extensive Supreme Court and High Court experience. For a defendant, that means someone who has seen how these claims run in the Family Provision List and can tell you early whether to defend firmly, negotiate or settle. We would rather give you a clear view of your risk in the first conversation than a hopeful one that falls apart at mediation.
We also work with executors who are caught between family and duty. If that is you, say so at the outset. It changes how we advise on distributions, communication with beneficiaries and who needs separate representation.
— George
How we can help
We act for executors, administrators and beneficiaries across Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW, in person or virtually. If you have been served, our Defend An Estate service covers responding to the Summons, preparing the estate affidavit, mediation and, if needed, the hearing. If you are the one considering a claim, see our family provision claims page.
Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you know where you stand before committing to anything. For people with a legitimate claim, this removes the upfront cost barrier that so often stops them from acting. Find out more on our No Win, No Fee page, then book a free case assessment and we will tell you whether your matter qualifies and what the practical next steps are.
No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Your next steps
Write down the date you were served and the return date on the Summons. Do not distribute assets. Gather the will, the asset and liability details, and any record of the deceased’s reasons. Then speak to a wills and estates litigator before you file anything. For the wider process, read our family provision claim process guide and eligibility and outcomes guide.
FAQ
Can I stop someone making a family provision claim against an estate?
Not completely. An eligible person can apply even if the will excludes them, and the court can order provision despite the will-maker’s wishes. You can reduce the risk through estate planning, written reasons and structuring assets, but a defendant’s real protection is a well-evidenced response once a claim is made.
How long does an applicant have to bring a claim in NSW?
Generally 12 months from the date of death. The court can extend that period if it finds sufficient cause, and the parties can also consent to a late application (Succession Act 2006 (NSW)). If you are close to or past that point, get advice on both sides of the question.
Do I have to go to mediation?
Most claims are referred to mediation, and parties are expected to attend in person unless exceptional circumstances apply (SC EQ 07). Claims that do not settle go to a final hearing. Treat mediation as a real chance to settle on terms you can live with.
Who pays if the claim fails?
The court decides. An unsuccessful applicant may be ordered to pay their own costs and the defendant’s (Legal Aid NSW). The court can also order costs from the estate, so the outcome depends on the facts and how each party has behaved.
Should I distribute the estate while a claim is pending?
Generally no. If assets are paid out and the court later orders provision, the estate may not have enough to meet it, and you could face personal difficulty as executor. Get advice before any distribution.
Sources
- Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
- Supreme Court Practice Note SC EQ 07 (PDF)
- SC EQ 07, Supreme Court of NSW
- The Family Provision Jurisdiction, Justice Lindsay (2021)
- Family provision claims, Legal Aid NSW
- Testamentary trusts vs. simple wills: an Australian guide
- Avoid trustee and tax pitfalls with testamentary trusts