Appointor vs Trustee: Who Holds the Real Power in a Family Trust?

The trustee runs the trust day to day. The appointor decides who the trustee is. In a family trust, the person holding the appointor role can hire and fire the trustee, so in practice they control the trust. When an appointor dies, who takes over is decided by the trust deed, and an unclear deed is a common source of estate disputes. At Simons George Legal we act for executors and beneficiaries in exactly these situations across Sydney and regional NSW.

Simons George Legal
simonsgeorgelegal.com.au
Get Advice on a Contested Estate
Simons George Legal advises executors and beneficiaries on inheritance disputes and estate litigation across Sydney and regional NSW.

Visit

TL;DR

  • The trustee holds the trust assets, makes decisions and owes duties to the beneficiaries. The appointor does not manage the trust but can appoint and remove the trustee.
  • Whoever is the appointor holds the real lever of control. That is why the role is often fought over after a death.
  • When an appointor dies, the trust deed decides the successor. If the deed is silent or badly drafted, the outcome can end up in court.
  • Trust assets generally sit outside a deceased estate, but NSW family provision law can reach some property that is not formally part of the estate.
  • If you are an executor or beneficiary caught in a trust dispute, get advice on the deed before anyone signs or resolves anything.

Table of Contents

The short answer: two roles, two kinds of power

A trust is a relationship, not a legal person. Someone (the trustee) holds property for the benefit of others (the beneficiaries). The Law Society of NSW explains that the trustee administers the trust, owes a duty directly to the beneficiaries and must always act in their best interests. All transactions for the trust are carried out by and in the name of the trustee.

The same page describes the appointor as very important because the appointor has the power to appoint and remove the trustee. The appointor does not sign contracts for the trust, buy or sell its property or decide distributions. Their power sits one level above: they choose who does those things.

Trustee Appointor
Main job Administers the trust and holds its assets Appoints and removes the trustee
Day-to-day decisions Yes: investments, distributions, record keeping No
Duties to beneficiaries Yes, fiduciary duties Depends on the deed and the circumstances; the role is usually described as a power rather than a management function
Named in the deed Yes Usually, with a successor mechanism
Can be a company Yes, commonly Yes, but this raises succession questions
Effect of death A new trustee must be appointed under the deed or statute The deed’s succession clause applies

Why the appointor is the real power in a family trust

Think of a trustee who is a company with two directors. The directors make every decision, but if the appointor wants them replaced, the appointor can use the deed’s power to do it. A trustee who knows this tends to keep the appointor onside.

That is why families, accountants and lawyers treat the appointor as the person who controls the trust. It is also why a deed that names one person as both a trustee and the sole appointor deserves a close look. A trustee who can only be removed by themselves is hard to hold to account.

For beneficiaries, the practical question is rarely “who is the trustee”. It is “who can change the trustee if the trustee does not act properly”. If you cannot answer that from the deed, the trust has a gap that will matter at the worst possible time, usually after a death.

What the trustee actually does and owes

The trustee is the legal owner of the trust assets. Their responsibilities generally include:

  • holding and investing trust property in line with the deed and the law;
  • making distributions to beneficiaries as the deed allows;
  • keeping accurate records and accounts;
  • acting in the interests of the beneficiaries, not their own.

A trustee can be an individual or a corporate trustee. Many family trusts use a company because it does not die, which keeps the trust’s assets in one name. But a company trustee does not solve the control question. Someone still controls the company, and someone still holds the power to replace it.

How an appointor appoints or removes a trustee

The starting point is always the trust deed. Where a deed gives a method for appointing trustees, that method must be followed. A 2017 paper on managing trusts explains that section 6 of the Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) allows a trustee to be appointed under that section, but always subject to the terms of the trust instrument.

In practice, the steps usually look like this:

  1. Read the deed. Confirm who the appointor is, how the power is exercised (a written resolution or deed of appointment, for example) and whether anyone else must consent.
  2. Prepare the document. The appointor signs the instrument the deed requires. Skipping the formality can make the change invalid.
  3. Secure the new trustee’s acceptance. The incoming trustee must be willing to act and take on the duties.
  4. Transfer the assets. Titles, bank accounts and registered property need to be updated to the new trustee’s name.
  5. Tell the people who need to know. That includes the accountant, lenders and the trust’s other advisers.

Where the appointor will not act, or there is no appointor, a beneficiary or other interested person may ask the Supreme Court of NSW to step in. Removing a trustee against their will is a court exercise with its own tests; our guide to removing a trustee in NSW covers the deed, statute and court steps.

What happens when the appointor dies

This is the question that brings most executors and beneficiaries to us. The answer is not in the general law. It is in the deed.

Some deeds name a successor appointor. Some let the last surviving appointor nominate a successor, often in their will. Some say that if nobody is nominated, the appointor’s legal personal representative (the executor of their will) takes the role. Some deeds say nothing.

Four deed-based routes for appointor succession

The Western Australian decision in Mercanti v Mercanti [2015] WASC 297 shows how much hangs on the wording. One deed provided that on the death of the last surviving appointor, a person appointed by that appointor would succeed, and if nobody was appointed, the legal personal representative would be entitled. Another deed’s variation power did not authorise the trustee to replace the appointor, so the attempted change did not work. The lesson is that courts read the specific deed. A label such as “appointor” or “principal” does not settle anything on its own, and a broad variation clause may work in one deed and fail in another.

If the appointor was also the will-maker

When the appointor was the person who died, there are two documents to read side by side: the trust deed and the will. The will may purport to nominate a successor appointor. Whether that nomination works depends on what the deed allows. If the deed says the appointor’s executor takes over, the executor has a new job on top of administering the estate, with duties and conflicts of interest that need careful handling.

If the deed is silent or the successor cannot act

A successor may be unwilling, incapacitated or already deceased. A deed may have no successor mechanism at all. The risks then include:

  • nobody having power to remove a trustee who is not performing;
  • the current trustee, often a company controlled by the deceased’s family, effectively answering to no one;
  • disputes between children, a surviving spouse, and children from earlier relationships about who takes control;
  • delay in distributions while the question is argued.

These cases frequently need a deed review first and, if the issue cannot be resolved by agreement, an application to the court. The earlier the deed is examined, the more options remain.

Why it matters in a contested estate

Executors and beneficiaries often assume that if a family trust held the family’s wealth, it forms part of the estate. Generally it does not. The Tasmanian Law Reform Institute’s 2019 report states that assets held within a trust, such as a family trust, do not form part of a person’s estate, apart from any beneficiary loan account the deceased had within the trust. It also notes that effective control of a trust during life does not make the trust’s assets part of the estate.

That has real consequences:

  • An executor’s reach is limited. The executor deals with the estate. They do not automatically control trust assets, unless they also inherit the appointor role under the deed.
  • A will may not touch trust wealth. A child left out of a will may find that most of the family’s wealth sat in a trust and passes by different rules.
  • Control passes separately. The person who becomes the appointor after a death may be someone other than the person who inherits under the will.

NSW law does provide some answers. Under section 63 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), a family provision order may be made in relation to property that is not part of the estate, or that has been distributed, if it is designated as notional estate by an order under Part 3.3 of the Act. In plain terms, the court has a tool to look past the formal ownership of some property when deciding whether an eligible person has received adequate provision. Whether that tool applies to a particular trust depends on the facts and on the deed. Our page on family provision claims explains who can apply and how claims work, and our article on constructive trust claims against an estate covers another route when someone says property is held for them.

Worked example: a farm trust and a missing successor

This is an illustration, not a real client matter. A couple in regional NSW run the family farm through a discretionary trust with a company trustee. The father is the sole appointor and one of two directors of the trustee company. The deed says that on his death his legal personal representative becomes appointor. His will names his eldest son as executor.

On his death, the son, as executor, steps into the appointor role. He can now replace the trustee company or its directors. His sister, who is a beneficiary of the trust but received a small gift under the will, believes the farm should be shared more evenly. She cannot compel distributions herself, but she may have claims: as a beneficiary against the trustee if duties are breached, and as an eligible person under the Succession Act if she can show she has not received adequate provision, with notional estate in play for some property.

Had the deed been silent on succession, nobody would hold the appointor power, and the company trustee would continue unchecked. That is the kind of gap a deed review should find while the people involved can still fix it.

Worked example: a farm trust and a missing successor

Practical steps for executors and beneficiaries

If you are dealing with a trust after a death, work through these in order:

  1. Get the complete trust deed and every amendment. Not a summary and not a copy of the first page.
  2. Find out who the appointor is now. Check the succession clause and any nomination in the deceased’s will.
  3. Check who the trustee is and who controls it. If it is a company, obtain the ASIC company details and the register of directors and shareholders.
  4. Do not distribute or transfer anything until the deed is read. Mistakes in the early weeks are hard to undo.
  5. List the time limits. Family provision claims in NSW are subject to a strict time limit running from the date of death, so do not wait to see how the trust question resolves.
  6. Collect documents. Our inheritance dispute documentation checklist sets out what to gather.

If you are an executor, remember that your role is to administer the estate properly. The steps in our executor checklist apply even where the family trust raises further questions.

Planning ahead: how to avoid the problem

Most of these disputes are avoidable at the drafting stage. A well-prepared family trust and will work together:

  • name a successor appointor, and a second successor in case the first cannot act;
  • consider whether one person should hold both the trustee and appointor roles, or whether power should be split;
  • make sure the will and the deed do not contradict each other;
  • review the deed when family circumstances change, such as a divorce, a remarriage, a business sale or the arrival of a child with special needs.

For families with blended structures, farms or businesses, a testamentary trust created under a will can add protection that a standard will cannot; see our guide to testamentary trusts and divorce protection. If you need to put your own affairs in order, our making and amending a will service and estate planning team can align your will with your trust arrangements.

Our view on appointor disputes

The appointor role is the one most families never think about until it is the only thing anyone is arguing about. People spend time choosing a trustee and almost none choosing who can replace the trustee.

Every matter at our firm is led by a partner with extensive Supreme and High Court experience, and that matters in trust disputes because the answers sit in the deed and in how courts read it. We start by reading the documents closely, then give you honest advice on your options, whether that is negotiation, mediation or court.

Where a dispute can be settled sensibly, we say so. Where it cannot, we act to protect your rights while keeping costs proportionate.

George

How we can help

Simons George Legal is a wills and estates practice based in Bondi, acting for executors and beneficiaries across Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW, in person or virtually. We act in estate litigation, advise executors on probate and estate administration and help clients defend an estate against a claim. New clients receive a complimentary 30-minute consultation, where we review your situation and recommend practical next steps.

Simons George Legal

Bring the trust deed, the will and any correspondence, and we will tell you who holds control and what your options are.

Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you learn early whether your matter qualifies. For people with a legitimate claim, this removes the upfront cost barrier that can otherwise stop them from acting. Book your free case assessment and we will tell you where you stand.

No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Where to start

If the trust deed names a clear successor and the trustee is acting properly, the transition after a death can be routine. If the deed is silent, the trustee is resisting or the family is divided, read the deed first and get advice before anyone signs a resolution. Decisions made in the first weeks often decide how a dispute ends.

FAQ

Can the trustee and the appointor be the same person?

The deed decides, and many family trusts do allow it. The risk is that nobody else can remove that person if they fail to act properly, so many advisers prefer to separate the roles or name more than one appointor. Where one person holds both roles, a beneficiary’s practical remedy may be a court application.

Who becomes the appointor when the appointor dies?

The person the trust deed says. That may be a named successor, a person nominated by the late appointor, or the appointor’s executor. If the deed is silent, the position is uncertain and may need to be resolved by agreement or by the court.

Is a family trust part of the deceased estate?

Generally no. Trust assets are held by the trustee, not the deceased, so they usually do not pass under the will. NSW family provision law can, however, reach some property outside the estate if it is designated as notional estate by the court.

Can a beneficiary remove a trustee?

A beneficiary usually cannot do it alone. The power normally belongs to the appointor under the deed. If there is no appointor or the appointor will not act, a beneficiary may apply to the Supreme Court of NSW, which will look at the deed, the trustee’s conduct and the interests of the beneficiaries.

Sources