Affidavit vs Statutory Declaration in NSW: What’s the Difference?

An affidavit is a written statement sworn or affirmed for use as evidence in court proceedings. A statutory declaration is a written statement declared true for situations where no court case is running but a fact still has to be proved, such as dealing with a government agency or a bank. In a contested estate, the document that carries your evidence to the Supreme Court of NSW is almost always an affidavit.

The two documents look alike. Both are written statements of fact, both are signed in front of an authorised witness, and both carry serious consequences if they are untrue. The differences lie in where each can be used, who can witness it, and what happens after you sign. This guide explains them in plain terms, with a focus on executors and beneficiaries dealing with wills, probate and inheritance disputes in NSW.

Simons George Legal
Prepare for an Estate Dispute
Simons George Legal advises on contested wills, family provision claims and estate litigation for individuals and families across Sydney.

Visit Simons George Legal

TL;DR

  • An affidavit is evidence for court proceedings and is sworn or affirmed. A statutory declaration is declared true to the best of your knowledge and belief and is used outside court.
  • In NSW courts, a witness’s evidence-in-chief must be given by affidavit unless the court orders otherwise, so estate litigation runs on affidavits.
  • A NSW Justice of the Peace, solicitor or barrister can witness a NSW statutory declaration. Commonwealth declarations use a different witness list.
  • Never sign either document beforehand. Sign in front of the witness, who must check your identity.
  • A false affidavit or statutory declaration is a criminal offence, so accuracy matters more than speed.

Table of Contents

The core difference in one minute

The NSW Land Registry Services guidelines describe an affidavit as a written statement normally given as evidence in court proceedings and sworn to be true, while a statutory declaration is declared true to the best of the maker’s knowledge and belief. The Law Handbook published by the State Library of NSW puts it the same way: affidavits are sworn or affirmed written facts used in court in place of spoken evidence, and statutory declarations are generally enough for non-court situations where a formal statement is required.

Three practical consequences follow.

  1. Purpose. An affidavit is built to be read by a judge or registrar. A statutory declaration is built to satisfy an agency, a registry or another organisation.
  2. Process. An affidavit used in court has to be filed and served on the other parties. The person who made it may still be required to attend court and answer questions about what it says, according to the Law Handbook.
  3. Formality. An affidavit is made by oath or affirmation, and the court’s rules dictate its layout. A statutory declaration follows a prescribed form.

Affidavit vs statutory declaration at a glance

Feature Affidavit Statutory declaration
Main use Evidence in court proceedings Proving a fact where there is no court case
How it is made Oath or affirmation Declaration that the contents are true and correct
Typical NSW setting Probate, family provision and other estate litigation Government forms, banks, registries, some estate administration steps
Format Court heading, numbered paragraphs, annexures, jurat NSW Eighth or Ninth Schedule form, or the Commonwealth form
After signing Filed and served; deponent may be questioned Handed to the organisation that asked for it
Who may witness A JP can witness affidavits for Australian courts and tribunals; solicitors and others may also act NSW JP, solicitor or barrister for NSW declarations
False statement Criminal offence Criminal offence

Why estate disputes run on affidavits

If you are an executor, a beneficiary or a family member considering a claim, the affidavit is the document you will meet most. The reason is procedural. Under rule 31.2 of the NSW Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, evidence-in-chief of a witness at any hearing must be given by affidavit unless the court orders otherwise. Your story, as the court first reads it, is your affidavit.

The NSW Supreme Court’s Probate and Family Provision List Practice Note (SC Eq 7) shows how heavily the process leans on them. It requires a family provision plaintiff to file and serve an affidavit with the summons, along with a notice of eligible persons and an affidavit estimating costs and disbursements. It also lets the Registrar in Probate direct an administrator to file an affidavit covering matters such as the deceased’s identity, the will, the assets and liabilities, property already distributed, eligible persons and beneficiaries.

In a family provision claim that usually means affidavits dealing with:

  • your relationship with the deceased and your financial circumstances
  • what you contributed to the deceased’s life or property
  • the size and nature of the estate
  • the needs of other beneficiaries

On the other side, an executor defending a claim files affidavits about the estate and the reasons behind the will. For background on the claim itself, see our guides on what a family provision claim is and the family provision claim process in NSW.

Can a statutory declaration replace an affidavit in an inheritance dispute?

As a starting point, no. Because the court rules make affidavit evidence the default for contested hearings, a statutory declaration is not a safe substitute for the sworn evidence the court expects. A statutory declaration is a statement that you declare to be true. An affidavit is evidence tendered to the court, in the form the court requires, which can be tested through questioning.

That does not make statutory declarations irrelevant in estates. They commonly turn up around the edges of a matter, for example to record a fact for an agency or a financial institution while an estate is being administered. Whether a particular document is acceptable for a particular purpose is decided by whoever is asking for it, or by the court in a proceeding. If a court, registry or institution has asked for one or the other, use what it asked for. If you are unsure, ask a solicitor before signing anything, because a document made in the wrong form can cost time and money.

The law also recognises that procedure can slip. Under the Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Act 2005 (Cth), a failure to follow the required procedure does not by itself automatically undo validity. Do not treat that as a safety net: it is far cheaper to get the form right the first time.

Can a statutory declaration replace an affidavit in an inheritance dispute?

Who can witness each document

Witness rules differ by document and by jurisdiction, and this is where people most often go wrong.

NSW statutory declarations. Legal Aid NSW states that a NSW statutory declaration may be witnessed by a NSW Justice of the Peace, a solicitor or a barrister. Commonwealth statutory declarations have their own list of approved witnesses, which includes medical practitioners among others. If the declaration is for a federal agency, check which form it requires before choosing a witness.

Affidavits. The NSW JP Handbook says a NSW JP may witness a statutory declaration for use in NSW, another state or territory, or the Commonwealth, and an affidavit required for an Australian court or tribunal, instrument registration or arbitration. In practice, most people in a contested estate sign their affidavits at their solicitor’s office, where the document has been prepared to the court’s requirements and the witness is properly qualified.

Witness eligibility by declaration type and affidavit

What the witness must do. The same handbook says the witness must verify your identity, check the document, hear the required declaration, watch you sign, and complete the jurat or signature panel. Failing to follow the required identity-check steps when witnessing a statutory declaration is an offence. So expect to bring photo identification, and expect to be asked to wait until the witness is ready before you sign.

How to write an affidavit for an estate matter

An affidavit is a legal document, and a poorly drafted one can damage a good case. The Law Handbook recommends the following approach, which our lawyers follow in estate litigation.

  1. Use the right heading or form. The court’s rules specify the title and layout. The NSW UCPR forms include a specific probate affidavit template covering the deceased and the will, attesting witnesses, the death, assets, liabilities, beneficiaries, executor status and the intended administration of the estate.
  2. Write in the first person. “I am the daughter of the deceased” rather than “the plaintiff is the daughter”.
  3. Number your paragraphs. Deal with one distinct matter in each paragraph.
  4. Stick to relevant facts you know first-hand. Non-expert opinion should generally be avoided, and so should what other people told you unless the court allows it.
  5. Annex or exhibit supporting documents. Bank statements, medical records, earlier wills and correspondence are referred to in the text and attached with proper identification.
  6. Address what the practice note requires. A family provision matter or a probate application carries specific content requirements.
  7. Sign in front of the witness, not before. Sign each required page in the presence of the authorised witness, then swear the oath or make the affirmation and let the witness complete the jurat.
  8. File and serve as directed. Missing a deadline can be as damaging as a flaw in the content.

You can choose between an oath and an affirmation. The JP Handbook states that an affirmation has the same legal effect as an oath and does not refer to God or a sacred object.

Before drafting, gather your records. Our inheritance dispute documentation checklist lists what is usually worth collecting.

How to write a simple statutory declaration

Statutory declarations are shorter and simpler. For a general NSW declaration, Service NSW identifies two formats, the Eighth Schedule and the Ninth Schedule forms. The JP Handbook sets out the steps:

  1. Use the Eighth or Ninth Schedule format and set out the facts, using the required wording.
  2. Leave the document unsigned until you are in front of an authorised witness.
  3. Prove your identity to the witness.
  4. Declare that the contents are true and correct to the best of your knowledge and belief.
  5. Sign in the witness’s presence, and have the witness complete the signature panel.

Keep the facts in numbered paragraphs, stay with what you know, and describe documents you refer to clearly. If the declaration is for a Commonwealth purpose, use the Commonwealth form and a witness from the Commonwealth list.

What happens if something in it is false

Both documents carry criminal consequences. The JP Handbook warns that making a false statutory declaration is a serious criminal offence with penalties that include imprisonment, and it identifies making a false affidavit as an offence with penalties too.

In an estate dispute there are practical risks as well. Credibility is often central, and an exaggerated or careless affidavit can be picked apart by the other side in cross-examination. Honest, measured and well-documented evidence is nearly always stronger than an emotional account.

Common mistakes in estate matters

  • Signing early. Signing before you are with the witness defeats the purpose and can invalidate the process.
  • Mixing fact and argument. An affidavit is for facts. Legal argument belongs in submissions.
  • Relying on hearsay. Reporting what others said, rather than what you saw or did, can lead to parts being rejected.
  • Forgetting the exhibits. A document mentioned but not properly annexed is of little use.
  • Using a stat dec where the court wants an affidavit. Check the form requirement first.
  • Leaving it late. Contested estate matters run to strict time limits. See our guide to contesting a will in NSW for the key deadlines, and the one on defending a family provision claim if you are the executor.

Get your evidence prepared properly

If you are an executor or beneficiary heading into a dispute, the affidavit is where your case is won or weakened. Simons George Legal is a Bondi-based wills and estates practice, and every matter is partner-led by a specialist with extensive Supreme and High Court experience. We act in estate litigation and family provision claims, and we prepare evidence with the court’s requirements in mind. New clients are offered a complimentary 30-minute consultation.

Simons George Legal

We work with clients across Sydney, the Eastern Suburbs, the Northern Rivers and regional NSW, in person or virtually.

Our view: evidence is built, not just signed

Most people arrive believing that the hard part is signing the paperwork. In our experience of contested estates, the hard part is deciding what the evidence needs to say, long before anyone meets a witness.

An affidavit is not a letter to the judge. It is the structure on which your claim or your defence stands. We design our matters so that each paragraph does a job: it establishes a relationship, a contribution, a need or a fact about the estate, and it points to a document that backs it up.

We aim to keep costs proportionate. That means preparing the right affidavits once, rather than redrafting after the other side has found the gaps. It also means telling you plainly when a short, simple statutory declaration is all that a task calls for, and when it is not.

Because every matter is led by a partner, the person who advises you on strategy is the person who shapes your evidence.

George

Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases. We check eligibility during a free initial consultation, so you know where you stand before committing to anything. For people with a legitimate claim, this removes the upfront cost barrier that can otherwise stop them from pursuing what they are entitled to. If you think you may have a claim, book a free case assessment today and we will tell you the practical next steps.

No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

FAQ

Who can witness a statutory declaration in NSW?

A NSW statutory declaration may be witnessed by a NSW Justice of the Peace, a solicitor or a barrister, according to Legal Aid NSW. Commonwealth declarations use a different list of approved witnesses. Always check which form your recipient requires before you book a witness.

Whose signature is required on an affidavit?

The person making the affidavit, called the deponent, must sign it in front of an authorised witness, who then completes the jurat. You swear an oath or make an affirmation at that point. Do not sign the pages before you are with the witness.

Is an affirmation as valid as an oath?

Yes. The NSW JP Handbook states that an affirmation has the same legal effect as an oath. It simply does not refer to God or a sacred object, so you can choose whichever suits you.

Can I use a statutory declaration in a will dispute instead of an affidavit?

Not as a general rule. NSW court rules make affidavits the default way of giving evidence at a hearing, and the Probate and Family Provision List requires affidavits at key steps. A statutory declaration may still help with administrative tasks around an estate. A solicitor can confirm which document your situation calls for.

How do I know if my affidavit is good enough?

It should follow the court’s required form, use numbered paragraphs, stay within your own knowledge and attach the documents it refers to. It also needs to cover whatever the applicable practice note requires for your type of matter. A solicitor experienced in estate litigation can review it before you swear it.

Sources