A testamentary trust can give an inheritance real protection in a future divorce, but it is not a guarantee. Australian family courts look at how the trust works in practice: who controls it, who benefits and why it was created. A trust set up in a will, with an independent trustee and a genuinely discretionary structure, is in a much stronger position than an inheritance paid straight into a child’s hands. This guide explains how the courts approach it and how to draft a will so the protection is as strong as it can be.
TL;DR
- A testamentary trust is created by your will and only starts on your death, so the assets never become your child’s personal property in the first place.
- In a property settlement, a court can treat a trust interest as property, or as a “financial resource” that affects the split. Control is the key factor.
- Making your child sole trustee with full control is the most common weakness. Independent or co-trustees and real discretion strengthen the structure.
- The protection is about reducing risk, not removing it. The will must be drafted for the family’s actual circumstances.
- Succession and trust rules vary between states, so NSW families need NSW-specific advice.
Table of Contents
- What a testamentary trust is
- How family courts treat a trust interest
- What the courts look at: the Mantel case
- Where testamentary trusts go wrong
- How to reduce the risk that an inheritance joins the pool
- Testamentary trusts in NSW
- Our perspective
- Getting the will drafted properly
- If a trust is challenged or an estate is disputed
- Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
- Next steps
- FAQ
- Sources
What a testamentary trust is
A testamentary trust is a trust created by the terms of a will that commences only upon the death of the testator. Instead of leaving a lump sum to a beneficiary outright, your will directs the executor to hold the assets on trust, with a trustee managing them for one or more beneficiaries under rules you set.
That difference matters in a marriage breakdown. When an inheritance is paid outright, it belongs to the beneficiary and can sit in the pool of assets that a court divides. When the same assets are held on trust, the beneficiary may have only a discretionary interest, or an interest that someone else administers. Whether that holds up depends on the facts, which is why the drafting matters so much.
If you are comparing structures, our guide to testamentary trusts versus family trusts sets out how they differ for children. For a broader look at whether you need a trust at all, see simple will versus trust.
How family courts treat a trust interest
The family law rules on property are federal, so they apply the same way in Sydney, Perth or Hobart. The Family Law Act 1975 allows the court to make property orders under sections 79 or 114, and Part VIIIAA permits orders that affect third parties in relation to a party’s property. In practice that means a trust is not automatically out of reach just because someone else holds the legal title.
The Queensland Law Handbook explains the practical distinction well. In summary:
| Situation | How a court is likely to treat it |
|---|---|
| A party controls the trust interest | May be treated as property and included in the pool |
| A party has an interest but does not control the trust | May be treated as a financial resource and dealt with through an adjustment |
| A party merely expects to inherit under a living person’s will | Ordinarily neither property nor a financial resource |
The last row is worth noticing. While you are alive, your child’s hope of inheriting from you is generally not something their spouse can claim. The risk arises after your death, when the inheritance becomes real.
Property versus financial resource
These two labels lead to different outcomes. If a trust interest is property, its value goes into the pool and is divided. If it is a financial resource, it is not divided, but it can be taken into account when the court considers each party’s future needs, so the spouse without the inheritance may receive a larger share of the other assets.
RSM Australia notes that a testamentary trust can be an effective way to define an inheritance as a financial resource rather than an asset of the marriage, while warning that the strategy carries pitfalls that need expert review. That is a sensible reading of the position: a well-built trust moves the inheritance from the first category towards the second, but it does not make it invisible.
What the courts look at: the Mantel case
The decision in Mantel and Mantel [2020] FamCA 157 is a useful illustration. The husband was trustee of a testamentary trust created by a deceased relative, but there were other beneficiaries as well. The court declined to treat 100% of the trust as property to which he was entitled. It accepted his evidence that he would administer the trust according to the will, and found the trust was not a sham and not a vehicle created from the parties’ own labour.
The trust was still a financial resource relevant under section 75(2)(o) of the Family Law Act, so it was not ignored. But the outcome shows what helped:
- The trust was created by a third party’s will, not by the couple.
- There were other beneficiaries, so the husband was not the sole person entitled.
- The trustee’s role was bounded by the terms of the will.
- There was no suggestion the structure was a device to defeat a spouse.
The court also acknowledged that honouring a deceased person’s wishes by not treating trust assets as a party’s personal property can be just and equitable. In other words, the intention of the person who made the will counts. A clear, well-documented intention to protect a child’s inheritance supports the outcome you want.
Where testamentary trusts go wrong
Most failures trace back to a handful of drafting and administration choices. None of these is a reason to avoid a trust. They are reasons to get the design right.
The beneficiary controls everything
If your child is the sole trustee, the only appointor and the main beneficiary, a court can see the trust as effectively theirs. Control is the factor courts return to repeatedly. Appointing an independent co-trustee, or a sibling, and limiting who can remove or replace trustees, helps preserve the separation between your child and the assets.
Treating trust money as personal money
A trust only protects assets if it is run as a trust. Paying personal expenses from trust funds without records, mixing trust and personal accounts, or treating the trust assets as one’s own all weaken the argument that the beneficiary has only a discretionary interest. Trustees should keep separate accounts and proper records of every distribution.
Receiving regular, predictable benefits
A beneficiary who receives steady distributions that fund the couple’s lifestyle may find the court gives the trust more weight when assessing resources. A discretionary structure where distributions are genuinely decided by the trustee, according to the needs of all beneficiaries, reads very differently from a trust that works like a pay packet.
Mixing in the couple’s own assets
A testamentary trust works best when it holds only what came from the estate. If the couple adds their own money, or the trust is used to hold assets built from their labour, the argument that it is separate from the marriage weakens. There are tax consequences too: income from a testamentary trust is not excepted income if it is generated from assets acquired by or transferred to the trustee on or after 1 July 2019 that are unrelated to the deceased estate, which matters for minors. Our article on testamentary trust tax rates covers this in more depth.
How to reduce the risk that an inheritance joins the pool
No structure removes the risk completely, and nobody can promise how a court will decide. These are the steps that, in our experience of drafting and disputing estates, give the best foundation.
- Decide who you are protecting and from what. Divorce is one risk. Creditors, bankruptcy, a vulnerable beneficiary and poor money habits are others. The design should reflect the real concern.
- Choose trustees deliberately. Consider an independent professional or trusted family member as a co-trustee, so the beneficiary does not hold unfettered control.
- Make the beneficiary’s interest discretionary. A beneficiary who has no fixed entitlement and who sits within a class of beneficiaries is in a different position from one entitled to everything.
- Include a wider class of beneficiaries. Grandchildren, siblings and other family members can be named, as the trustee in Mantel had other beneficiaries to consider.
- Record your reasons. A short, signed statement of wishes explaining why you chose a trust gives a court evidence of your intention.
- Keep the trust separate. Advise your beneficiaries to run the trust properly and not to commingle funds.
- Review the will regularly. Family circumstances, tax rules and case law move on. A will written years ago may no longer fit.
If your child is already separating, or you suspect they might, the position is more delicate. Our guide to the impact of separation on inheritance explains what to consider before changing a will.
Testamentary trusts in NSW
The family law property rules are federal, but the trust itself, its administration, variation and any estate dispute depend partly on state law. The NSW Law Reform Commission has noted that succession laws differ across the states and territories, including will formalities, intestacy rules and family provision rights.
There is a specific NSW point to be aware of. A 2024 paper by 13 Wentworth Chambers states that NSW’s court power to vary trusts is narrower than in Queensland, Victoria, South Australia, Tasmania and Western Australia, because NSW generally permits variation only where it benefits the beneficiaries as a whole. The practical lesson is to draft with flexibility built in from the start, because you cannot count on the court to repair a rigid trust later.
Interstate articles, including those written for Western Australia or Queensland, are helpful on the federal principles but should not be relied on for NSW drafting.
Our perspective
We act for families on both sides of this issue, and that shapes how we draft. We see wills that were meant to protect a child but left them as sole trustee with total control, and we see the arguments that follow when the marriage ends.
Our view is that a testamentary trust is one of the most useful tools in estate planning, provided it is designed for the particular family and not copied from a template. The questions we ask are practical: who will really run this trust, who else is in the class of beneficiaries, and what would a court see if it looked at the trust in ten years?
Every matter at our firm is partner-led by a specialist with extensive Supreme and High Court experience. That means the person advising you on the drafting also understands how these structures are tested when a dispute reaches court. We aim to give clear, honest advice and to be transparent about fees.
The best time to build protection into a will is while everyone is on good terms. Doing it after a separation starts is harder, and sometimes too late.
George
Getting the will drafted properly
If you are thinking about a testamentary trust for your children, we can review your family circumstances and draft a will that sets out the trust, the trustees and your reasons clearly. Our will drafting and amendment service covers new wills and updates to existing ones, and our wider estate planning team can advise on blended families, business assets and farm succession where a trust needs to work alongside other structures.
New clients are offered a complimentary 30-minute consultation, so you can talk through your situation before deciding anything.
If a trust is challenged or an estate is disputed
A testamentary trust does not stop a family member from contesting a will. An eligible person who believes they have been left too little can make a family provision claim, and a trust may form part of the argument about what the estate should provide. If you are an executor or trustee defending a claim, our guide to defending a family provision claim in NSW sets out the process. If you are a beneficiary who wants to understand your position, see beneficiary rights in a contested estate.
When the person who died left a trust and the beneficiary is now in a relationship breakdown, the trustee has a difficult job. They must follow the will, keep accurate records and respond to requests for information from the other side’s lawyers. Early legal advice helps the trustee avoid steps that could harm the beneficiary or expose the trustee personally. Our estate litigation team acts for executors, trustees and beneficiaries in these situations.
Funding Your Legal Matter — No Win, No Fee
Cost should not stop someone with a legitimate claim from getting advice. Simons George Legal offers No Win, No Fee arrangements for eligible cases, which removes the upfront cost barrier for people with a genuine claim. Eligibility is checked during a free initial consultation, where we assess the facts and explain the options in plain terms. You can read more on our No Win, No Fee page. If you think you may have a claim, book a free case assessment today and we will tell you honestly where you stand.
No Win, No Fee arrangements are subject to case eligibility and a written costs agreement. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Next steps
A testamentary trust is a strong tool for protecting an inheritance from a future divorce, but its strength comes from the detail: trustees, discretion, beneficiaries, records and your written intentions. Start by listing the people you want to protect, the assets involved and who you trust to act as trustee. Then get advice on how to put that into your will before circumstances change.
FAQ
Can a testamentary trust protect an inheritance from divorce in Australia?
Often it can reduce the risk, but it cannot guarantee protection. A court can treat a trust interest as property if the person controls it, or as a financial resource that affects the division of other assets. Independent trustees, a wider class of beneficiaries and proper administration all help.
Is my husband or wife entitled to half of my inheritance?
There is no automatic half share. Property settlements in Australia are decided on what is just and equitable, and an inheritance received before or during the relationship can be included in the pool. How it is treated depends on its form, its size and what the court considers fair. A mere expectation of inheriting from someone still alive is ordinarily not property.
How is a testamentary trust established?
It is set up through the terms of a will. The will names the trustee, the beneficiaries and the rules for managing the assets, and the trust begins only when the will-maker dies and the estate is administered. A lawyer should draft it, because small wording choices affect control, tax and protection.
Does a testamentary trust work the same way in every state?
The federal family law rules are the same, but trust administration, variation and succession law differ between states. NSW, for example, has a narrower court power to vary trusts than several other states, so drafting for NSW needs to be specific.
Do I need a testamentary trust if my child is happily married?
Marriages change, and a will is meant to work for decades. A trust costs more to draft and administer than an outright gift, so it is worth discussing whether the protection is worth it for your family. We can help you weigh that up.
Sources
- Testamentary trusts, Public Trustee (South Australia)
- Family Law Act 1975 (compilation, 10 June 2025)
- Property Orders for Separating Couples, Queensland Law Handbook
- Can inheritance be protected in Family Law Proceedings?, RSM Australia
- Mantel and Mantel [2020] FamCA 157, CaseChat AU
- Your income if you are under 18 years old, Australian Taxation Office
- Uniform Succession Laws, Issues Paper 10, NSW Law Reform Commission
- Problematic Taxation Issues in Estate Administration, 13 Wentworth Chambers (2024)